Asset-Based Finance: Complexity as a Competitive Moat
As direct lending has matured, its underwriting methodology has converged. Analysis anchored on EBITDA multiples, leverage ratios and covenant packages applied to a single corporate borrower is portable across managers and deals
·
6 min read

As direct lending has matured, its underwriting methodology has converged. Analysis anchored on EBITDA multiples, leverage ratios and covenant packages applied to a single corporate borrower is portable across managers and deals. This portability naturally allows managers to scale efficiently, though it also increases the number of managers arriving at similar risk evaluations. Where methodology is standardized, barriers to entry fall, and the last decade has seen sustained manager entry into a field that now bids competitively for substantially similar assets. The predictable consequence has been spread compression as the market moves towards a clearing rate: McKinsey reports median direct lending spreads falling from 650 basis points in 2023 to 544 in 2025. Direct lending accounted for 58.4% of all private debt capital raised in 2024, while by the first quarter of 2026 PitchBook data placed that figure at around 31%. Meanwhile, through the first three quarters of 2025, specialty finance overtook direct lending in new fund launches for the first time, at 84 against 71.
Asset-based finance has been a key beneficiary of that reallocation within the private credit market. Pool-level underwriting rests on capability that does not transfer readily from corporate credit analysis including, loss curve modelling, prepayment behaviour analysis, servicer quality assessment and collateral valuation, alongside the origination relationships through which proprietary flow is sourced. As Laura Hirst, a distinguished Partner at the forefront of Ropes & Gray’s pioneering Credit Funds practice, notes, “where the underlying types of assets themselves vary; for example, consumer loans, trade receivables, equipment leases, royalties and digital infrastructure, each carries its own regulatory, servicing and risk profile and as a result potentially different market terms”. From a fund manager’s perspective, this heterogeneity creates a stronger complexity premium for managers able to serve the market effectively. Invesco reports that ABF lending can offer a premium of 150 to 400bps over direct lending, and while a proportion of this can be attributed to risk, underwriting complexity and constrained origination access are also contributory factors.
There is a similar appetite for reallocation from the LP side. While direct lending remains the core focus, around 70% of institutional LPs forecast greater private credit diversification over the next 12 months, just 6% indicate an intention to increase exposure to upper- and mid-market direct lending, and 58% anticipate rising portfolio issues for direct lenders[]. As intent to diversify grows, ABF lending becomes a particularly attractive option, since repayment depends on the contractual performance of a large and diversified body of underlying obligors rather than on a single borrower's operating results, placing ABF exposure at a meaningful remove from the corporate credit cycle. For institutions already carrying substantial concentration in leveraged corporate credit, that decorrelation is attractive irrespective of any spread advantage. The fundraising data bears this out. Specialty finance accounted for 5% of private credit fundraising in 2023 and 3.6% in 2024, but raised $37 billion in 2025, more than the previous two years combined and second only to direct lending at $79 billion. McKinsey, working from Preqin data, arrives at a comparable conclusion by a different route, estimating that closed-end funds pursuing ABF opportunities raised approximately $27.1 billion through 2025 to capture 16.4% of all closed-end private credit fundraising[][].
On a day-to-day level, the most focused impact of this trend may be incident on credit funds tax practitioners. As Dan Paulos, a leading figure in EY’s global Credit Funds team and the industry at large, articulates, “Asset-based finance funds do not introduce fundamentally new tax issues for credit strategies. Instead, they amplify a familiar set of challenges that credit funds have long navigated”.
One component of this is that the heterogeneous income characteristics of ABF funds can require more granular evaluation to determine tax-optimal structuring and whether blocking properly belongs at asset or fund level. For example, an equipment lease pool may generate fully taxable UBTI where an economically comparable receivables pool generates none. Collateral type and other commonly varying characteristics of ABF lending, such as the type of warehouse leverage, the intensity of any servicing role and the retention of residual or equity strips in securitization structures, each bear on the trade-or-business analysis differently.
Paulos notes, however, that the bigger challenge comes from the heightened risk of loan-origination taint posed by ABF funds: “The growing reliance on forward-flow arrangements in the ABF space brings particular focus to questions of whether an originator’s activities should be imputed to the buyer”.
When no single structuring solution ports cleanly across collateral types, clients require bespoke solutions to cater to unique needs. As Paulos puts it, “while these issues are not novel, the current market emphasis on ABF structures is prompting both managers and originators to pursue more tailored and innovative approaches to managing the associated tax considerations”. The immediate consequence is a heightened premium on attorneys with sufficient practice depth across both tax and credit fund formation. While the constituent disciplines are not rare, the intersection is, and the relative newness of the sub-practice, combined with a previously more siloed approach to these questions, means the population of attorneys able to meet both requirements remains thin.
From a fund formation perspective, Hirst observes, “Our clients are constantly innovating and evolving their strategies and products to keep pace with a constantly changing market. The growth in asset-based finance (ABF) credit funds is a good example of that”. But practice leaders may need to consider that practitioners with genuine depth in ABF will remain scarce for as long as the work resists standardization, and that retention and the ability to develop these practice capabilities in junior associates will be critical. As Hirst explains, “to advise our clients on their fund structures and terms, we have to understand their business and what sits underneath the fund. This understanding is important not only for partners, but also for our associates”. Experience in this sub-practice may be less easily learned through repetition of the most basic tasks, since successive matters do not necessarily strongly resemble one another. For leaders like Hirst, this places increased emphasis on a development strategy that prioritizes equipping associates with a broad foundational knowledge base and an ability to understand the nuance of client needs. “We train associates on the fundamentals of a wide range of fund structures, both open-end and closed-end and we also teach them about the underlying asset classes and how they shape a fund's structure and key terms. We're deliberate about how we use technology and AI. Junior lawyers now spend less time on the routine mechanics of launching a fund, which frees them to focus on substance: the structuring choices, the commercial drivers and the conversations with clients are where they learn the most and can add the most value”.
In other words, complexity cuts both ways; the resistance to standardization that lets ABF managers defend their margins also shapes the market for the attorneys who advise them. Firms whose credit platform capabilities do not extend beyond direct lending, may find that the expertise ABF requires is hard to hire and slow to train. The practices that come out ahead are likely to be those that recognize early that a credit funds tax partner with real ABF depth is worth competing for in the lateral market, and that the associates they develop and retain are, for the same reasons, similarly valuable, both to the firm and its competitors.
Share
More in Industry News
Newsletter
Subscribe to Market Insights
The IFLD newsletter on the investment funds legal market, sent by email.




